Manager musings: more free press legislation needed

Manager musings: more free press legislation needed

Sterling Cosper/Manager

Constitutional amendment, FOIA

OKMULGEE, Okla. — At the beginning of this year, the Muscogee (Creek) Nation Administration Department mandated that MCN employees complete an online ethics training video and quiz originally composed by the FBI.

In this video, the agency used examples of fiscal corruption in tribal governments and pointed to a lack of free press as one of the reasons problems like this go unreported and are allowed to continue.

MCN took a big step towards addressing this issue in 2015 with the passing of a free press law.

However, this law has limitations regarding the potential longevity of these protections and how strong it makes Mvskoke Media in the checks and balances system next to the other three branches of tribal government.

Since becoming manager, I have brought these concerns to the attention of several members of the government and now want to include you, the citizens in the conversation as the true bosses of the tribe.

Constitutional amendment

The first concern related to our bill regards how it was passed into law and thus, how it can be undone through the same process.

As we sit now, Mvskoke Media is known as an independent statutory executive agency.

This means we were added to the tribal code of law through majority vote of the National Council with the signature of the principal chief.

Council also had the ability to override an executive branch veto of this bill with a two-thirds majority vote, which also applies to undoing the legislation now that it is passed.

Even though the government could reverse this law, the existence of it is a big step because it could not be done without high profile political fallout that would cause great need to answer for such a decision.

While this is a fairly effective deterrent to making such a decision, the future of an important law like free press should not be questionable or left to chance.

This is why these protections should be added to the foundational law of our Nation, the MCN Constitution.

There are a number of ways to amend the Constitution, all of which involve a direct vote of the citizens and most importantly, this is also the only way to undo it.

Freedom of Information Act

Transparency is the key motivation for having a free press law and the best enhancement to this is a freedom of information act.

FOIAs provide a legal mechanism for news outlets, interest groups and ordinary citizens to compel the government to release documents that show how it is handling the mission of public service.

We as journalists are not here to publish news content based on our assessment and opinions.

Editorial content involving staff opinions like this piece has a place in our mission of being a voice and advocate for the citizens with very specific ethical guidelines in how it is done and separated from news coverage.

However, it is our main job to get all sides of an issue from those involved in it through news coverage that keeps our own assertions out of the picture.

While accounts and opinions are essential to this, it still raises the question, ‘how can a source prove these?’

Relying solely on statements and testimony to prove something can be labeled as hearsay in the legal world to discredit it.

Such a label is intended to raise doubt about the assumed trust that happens when relying exclusively on a human assessment of something without any evidence to prove it.

Getting this kind of solid evidence as a news outlet is difficult with no legal means to compel the government to release documents and information pertinent to an issue.

This often leaves the outlet with only hearsay to try and get the best representation of a situation or to even have enough credible facts to begin pursuing coverage of it.

Again, a FOIA would give us hard evidence to pursue an important issue and get a better picture of it once we do, as well as give citizens direct power of access to matters they consider important.

There are commonly still limitations to what can be disclosed through a FOIA.

Requests for information on personnel issues and proprietary business dealings that could compromise said dealings for the tribe would commonly be denied or redacted.

However, guidelines can be included in a FOIA about these concerns and how they are handled.

Consider this as a call to action. Please educate yourself about tribal free press and lobby your officials to support us in passing further protections for the future of MCN.

STERLING COSPER Mvskoke Media Manager 918.732.7697 | Sterling was born in Wichita, Kan., and graduated from Wichita State University. His father’s side of the family is based out of Henryetta, Okla., and he started as a reporter with ‘Muscogee Nation News’ in January 2012. He is a music fan, mostly of the instrumental jazz and world genres when he is busy and a broad variety of others when he is not.


Latest Posts

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *


  • Tom Burtnett
    May 26, 2017, 9:46 am

    This is a very informative article written by the Mvskoke Media manager. I certainly agree 100% with him on pushing to get a FOIA passed for the CITIZENS of Muscogee (Creek) Nation. Elected officials might be hesitant to want to push this since it can and will disclose wrong doings among our elected officials. We must remember these elected officials are there to work for the good of ALL citizens not just the chosen few! We are a Nation of over 83,000 citizens and we should ALL have the save rights and benefits! Expanding the Freedom of the Press and successfully getting Freedom of Information Act for the citizens of MCN needs to be done NOW! It is 2017 and we need to move our Nation forward in a progressive way. Stop the old mentality of many of our enrolled members. Many of them are afraid of CHANGE and that is why we sometimes end up being at the back of the bus! FOIA Now!

    • Aaron Griffith @Tom Burtnett
      May 26, 2017, 8:25 pm

      A constitutionally established, independent, non profit, MCN free press and FOIA should proceed as a ballot measure, by initiative petition if necessary, if the National Council cannot be compelled to put it on the ballot in the next regular election.

  • […] I still hope to work towards progress on other matters I addressed in the past such as a freedom of information act and freedom of press amendment for the … […]